Why don't vegans eat eggs from their own home-raised chickens? After all, the chickens have a nice life, don't they? Probably you already know, Why vegans do not eat eggs from factory farming. But what actually speaks against the eggs from happy chickens that live on their own farm? Admittedly, this is a much-discussed topic that is rarely agreed upon, because the animals are already much better off than in extreme situations. Factory farming.
Nevertheless, I would like to present you here eight reasons that, in my opinion, also speak against the consumption of eggs from happy chickens in your own garden. Let's go!
In advance already a short Overview for you:
- Buying a chicken supports the egg industry system
- Chickens naturally lay significantly fewer eggs
- Eggs actually contain food for chicks
- It continues to be exploitation
- Chickens eat their own eggs
- The excessive egg production endangers the chicken
- Often chicken owners kill their animals when the "performance" decreases
- Backyard eggs are also cholesterol bombs
- It is easier to change a habit if you do without it altogether
Why don't vegans eat eggs from their own farm?
The "backyard eggs" (english: backyard eggs) may be significantly more animal friendly and also vegans often bring to the point where you ask yourself the question "yes what exactly is actually bad about it?". After all, there is often regional food, the animals usually have free run and can interact socially with other animals and people on their own property. Nevertheless, there are also certain aspects that do not go hand in hand with the vegan lifestyle are compatible.
Therefore, let's not 'long' chatter and come directly to the point. For the following briefly and crisply explained motives, I as a vegan refrain from eating eggs from my own farm.
1. because the purchase of the chicken still supports the egg industry
When we buy the chicken from a farmer or breeder, we are supporting the egg industry, in which Chicks shredded or gassed and laying hens are killed as soon as they become "unproductive. This is not in the spirit of veganism.
But suppose we rescue a chicken from a slaughterhouse or take it over free of charge from a farm: what's wrong with that?
2. because chickens naturally lay significantly fewer eggs
The Bankiva Chicken, the wild parent form of the domestic chicken, lays only about 10 - 15 eggs a year.₁ "Modern" laying hens produce However, more than 300 eggs a year₂ because we consider it a high-performance machine and have bred it to perform that way.
Besides, we just take the egg away from the chicken - and for this very reason it lays the next one a short time later. Therefore, it would be more animal-friendly to let the unfertilized egg incubate until the animal itself realizes that it is not fertilized. As a result, it will leave the hatchery and not constantly feel the need to replace it directly again.
3. because chicken eggs are actually the food of chicks
The proteins, fat, carbohydrates and other nutrients in an egg are not made to be eaten by us humansbut serve as food for unborn chicks. Another reason to also give up eggs from their own chickens.
4. because it is still exploitation
Mostly chickens from their own breeding continue to be a means to an end. It still goes in profit, albeit on a small scale. Most people want to eat the eggs and sell them, or intend to hand the animal over to a butcher at some point. Whether you take money for it or not - or eat it all yourself or not: the chicken in such cases will be treated like a resourcewhose life value depends only on what it does for us. But this Animals are sentient beings and deserve a right to freedom, just like we humans do. This is a major reason why vegans do not eat eggs from their own chickens.
5. because chickens eat their own eggs
The Egg production costs the chicken valuable nutrients - especially when it lays so many eggs! The vitamins and minerals from the contents, and not least the calcium from the eggshell itself, are incredibly important for the health of the animal. That's why laying hens often eat their own eggs to absorb the nutrients they need. In this way, the eggs from your own farm are not "wasted" either, if you refrain from eating them.
6. because the excessive egg production endangers the life of a chicken
When chickens produce eggs, they consumed nutrients for it. The lack of nutrients like Calcium (for the eggshell) is the main reason why animals so often suffer from osteoporosis and bone fractures. Corresponding deficiencies can also be a life-threatening problem become for chickens in their own keeping. For example, if an egg gets stuck in the cloaca of the chicken. The yolk can also settle in the body and lead to infection with E.coli bacteria and thus to peritonitis. The latter results in death over time if not treated.₃
For these reasons, as a true chicken lover, you'd better feed their eggs back to them and make sure they lay as few eggs as possible.
Notice: A small hormone implant opens up the possibility of preventing the chicken from laying eggs so that it can retain the nutrients. Even if this seems unnatural, it works against the high performance of the animals trained by us humans.
7. because many backyard chicken owners also kill their animals
Many chicken owners (whether large or small scale) kill their animals as soon as they eat their own eggs instead of letting them absorb the nutrients. This is also indicative of the fact that one animal mainly from egoistic motives keeps, since it is killed immediately, as soon as it no longer fulfills its "purpose". That this behavior of laying hens, however, is health-promoting for the animal, should actually bring joy to the most profit-hungry people in the long run.
8. because eggs from happy chickens are also cholestar bombs.
Proteins, of course! But the eggs with 417 milligrams per 100 grams the most cholesterol-rich food in the world is something that advertising likes to hide from us.₄
Why should we eat something that is not vital and endangers our health? Just out of habit? Who Prevent heart disease would like, should among other things really rather completely do without eggs, no matter whether they come from cage, free-range or own attitude.
9. because it is easier to break a habit if you do without it altogether.
As a vegan, I also eat neither eggs from factory farming nor from my own rearing, because doing without makes it much easier for me not to make an exception. Because if I would continue to consume eggs from my own husbandry, the temptation would be much greater when visiting a restaurantto eat a dish with egg, even if this does not come from happy chickens. The latter can at least not be determined with absolute certainty, as it would only be with their own attitude at home.
So vegans also do without eggs from their own chickens
Simply because it is the Most animal friendly behavior is. The life of the laying hen on a large plot may already be much better than in the narrow, dark cages with thousands of their peers and only a few centimeters of space. But it can be even better! Why not give preference to that? The animals have done nothing to us and deserve to live a truly happy and long life.
I hope that in this post I was able to give you a deeper insight into the motives of vegans not to eat eggs from happy, home-raised chickens either.
Do you have questions or suggestions about eggs from your own chickens? Then write me a comment!
Stay pet friendly,
PS.: Look you with pleasure still something in the Animal welfare blog. There you will also learn, why i live vegan at all. Have fun!
₁ Zentrum für alte Haus- und Nutztierrassen e.V.: Bankivahuhn, available at https://www.arche-warder.de/tiere/bankivahuhn. [13.07.2021].
₂ German Federal Ministry of Food and Agriculture (BMEL): Neue Wege für mehr Tierwohl - Ein Magazin des Bundesministeriums für Ernährung und Landwirtschaft, 1st edition, January 2016, p. 7.
₃ Surge Campaigning C.I.C: Why don't vegans eat backyard eggs?, available at https://www.surgeactivism.org/backyardeggs. [13.07.2021].
₄ Deutsche Herzstiftung e.V.: Cholesterol - How can heart patients protect themselves?, available at https://www.herzstiftung.de/cholesterin.html. [07.05.2020].
thank you for your interesting contribution.
I have been living vegan for half a year and I am still absolutely convinced of it. To do something good, I am currently considering rescued chickens from factory farming to take in my garden.
Of course, I would provide the best possible care for the hens and offer them as large and varied a run + coop, etc. as possible.
The only question is what I do with the eggs. Since these are spent laying hens, they probably still lay 4-5 eggs a week, which from experience (from other keepers) is not prevented by leaving eggs in the nest. Often, the chickens probably also make no effort to eat their own eggs, so that they would actually simply mold and you would have to dispose of them.
And sure - of course the chickens can live happily with me for the rest of their lives, regardless of their laying performance.
I understand your reasoning, however, in my example I see no real reason not to consume the eggs.
But I am very happy to be proven wrong! The topic currently occupies me very much and I have not yet formed my final opinion about it.
Would you actually rather let eggs go moldy than eat them or give them to family/acquaintances because of me?
I would be very happy to receive a reply!
thank you for your feedback, input and opinion on the post.
I think your idea is great and if you take them in as friends (like dogs and cats) and don't sell their (not self-eaten) eggs, which they inevitably lay because of their past, but give them away to Family & Friends, I don't see a problem there at all.
Only I would eat them personally - simply because that does not fit to the vegan attitude to life and one out of habit perhaps also outside of the own four walls rather times again an egg is.
By the way, I always have a hard time with the word "instruct". In the end, everyone decides for themselves what to do. I can only tell you how I would personally handle the situation.
I wish you maximum success in your awesome endeavor and have a great time with your cackling friends 🙂 .
Feel free to send me a picture when you have them with you. I always find that exciting.